Soulful Kinda Music

Magazine & Web Site

Just click on the link back to the main Artist Discography page if you want to check another one out. Or click on the link for the home page for access to other pages.

Dave Godin Page

Home Page


Dave Godin's column for Soulful Kinda Music. Issue 23

Sadly, some bad news to open with this time. The death of Junior Walker (who, amazingly, made it to the Radio 4 morning news programme), and finally, confirmation that Larry Banks did die "about two years ago". Also, (both from Multiple Sclerosis), Stuart Henry, a DJ who did Soul music a lot of favours back in the 60s, and the writer Brigid Brophy, who, though not involved in the Soul scene, opened "Soul City" record store in Deptford High Street back in the mid-sixties, and in her opening speech said "It is highly significant and important, that this record shop is devoted not just to music, but a particular sort of music". Although the "cause" of Soul music is still championed in some quarters, it is NOT defeatist to admit that, like the Republicans in the Spanish Civil War, we LOST. We didn't take the castle, we didn't convert the masses, but, that said, like the Republicans, that doesn't mean our cause was wrong, misguided or our defeat ignoble. Now, perhaps even more so than when the music was in its full flower of creativity and magic, we can see even more clearly how brilliant, how life-affirming and how enduring it was. But, that alone is perhaps the best form of victory because we have been vindicated, but, on the other hand, to pretend that there is still some last remnant of hope that our dwindling ranks will regroup and make one last gallant stand, is to ignore the reality of cultural history over the last 50 years. All periods in history have their own particular and peculiar abstract qualities, and, although one can still deeply enjoy the artefacts of the past, time and the cultural mood has passed on, and the collective rhythm of the human heart is now beating to a different tempo to what it was in the golden era of Blackamerican Soul music. But, wasn't it GREAT to have dug it all when it was NEW... and who could possibly take away from you that transitory, but indelible, life experience? If life does have any meaning, it is all about this; what you are able to respond to, and what you are able to give back into the pool of human experience. 

The music scene in Blackamerica has so changed over the years, as more and more labels and artists have set up in brief and transitory business, that it is often difficult to know just what are the great, the good and the not-so-good sides. Geared-in, as most everything is, to money, it is easy for critics to forget that their first duty should only be to their readers, and not ensuring their name stays on a record company's mailing list or not alienating potential advertisers, and the hardest part of record criticism is realising that it's no good just saying a side is GREAT; but trying to explain in some detail WHY it's great. So, ever willing to try and put my money where my mouth is, I thought it about time I revived "Significant Sides", the occasional feature I used to carry in my column in which I spotlighted records which I thought had lasting quality and were worth seeking out, and on which, every fortnight, I staked what "reputation" people were kind enough to bestow upon me. With the CD revolution, the field of re-issues and classic sides, sometimes being issued for the first time ever over here, (albeit with often dubious legality), I thought I'd trawl through the catalogues and see what's on offer that I consider indispensable. It is also safe to assume that if I've spotlighted a track here, then in my view, that track alone is worth the cost of the entire CD it is featured on. 

THE VASHONETTES "A MIGHTY GOOD LOVER" (Written by L. Webber and Leonard Caston) CHECKER 1195 available on CHARLY CD "Sweeter Than The Day Before" CDARC 515.

Produced by Leonard Caston and arranged by Charles Stepney, The Vashonettes' outing is a cracker of the first order, and yet failed to do anything in the American charts when it was first released, but this is an old, old story, and, as I've often repeatedly said, commercial success is NOT necessarily the same as, nor necessarily bestows, QUALITY. And too, many's the time I've sung the praises of the CHESS/CHECKER outfit (not forgetting the CADET and ARGO labels too, or their obscure CHECKMATE label), who always seemed willing to give new talent a whirl and a chance, picking up outstanding masters from tiny indie labels, and often, whirling them up into sizeable hits. A strutting, sassy, brass-dominated pace opens the side, with a delicious femme group chanting a pretend-bored "Oo ooo yeah", and the lead singer enters with a voice pitched midway between teen and woman, as she proceeds to extol the virtues of her lover who can "make a fool out of Casanova". (Tell that to Ruby Andrews!). Full of all the no-nonsense drive so typical of Chicago sides, this is a classic that should be in every Soul collection, and creates its addictive tension through a combination of love-struck surrender and the usual Chicago street-wise "don't take my sweetness for weakness"! Chicago is self-evidently an environment that forces women to become emancipated, and they don't come much more so than The Vashonettes! 

DENISE LASALLE "A LOVE REPUTATION" (Written by L. Baker & W. R. Emerson) CHESS 2005 available on CHARLY CD "Sweeter Than The Day Before" CDARC 515.

Having reviewed this record when it was new in 1966, it is remarkable how well it still stands up; the sure insignia of a classic if ever there was one. Originally issued on the local TARPON label, it was picked up by CHESS for national distribution, although again, hit status mysteriously eluded it. Part of this particular record's great strength lies in the arrangement; the hypnotic hook line delineated with piano and rhythm section, which moves at a slightly more urgent pace than the melody of the song itself. Try imagining the vocal track by itself, and you'll see what I mean. There is a certain celebratory feel to this side as well, and maybe its psychological appeal is so strong because it speaks of so much that society denies us! If you let it, that is! Strange that the Women's Movement, which of course is dominated by theorising academics and self-styled intellectuals, should be so totally ignorant and oblivious to the very radicalism of sides like this which impress their message rather than spell it out! Magic! 

One might have thought that the CHESS/CHECKER catalogues had by now been thoroughly milked and every "lost gem" and "forgotten treasure" exploited, but... there are still a few Cinderella sides that languish in the vaults... Who would ever have reckoned at the time, that the decade from 1960 to 1970, would have provided such an explosion and upsurge in Blackamerican creativity that we'd carry on feasting on it well into the 21st century? And hand it all on for the next generation to relish too! 

JIMMY REED "SHAME, SHAME, SHAME" (Written by Jimmy Reed) VEE JAY Unknown number available on CHARLY CD "20 R&B DANCE FLOOR FILLERS" CDRB 23

The late Jimmy Reed is perhaps undergoing something of an eclipse in status at present, but, in his day, one could hardly wait to hear his latest release. I remember my mate Mick Ashby had an aunt in the States who used to send him records, and one Monday, he phoned me at work to tell me that he'd just received Jimmy Reed's latest LP from the States... I could hardly sleep in anticipation of hearing it the following weekend! Such was our innocence in this far off days! But, there is still a potent quality about Jimmy Reed. All great art in my view is almost always simple, and sides hardly came more starkly simple than Reed's VEE JAY output; but oh, the conviction they carried, and the pure poetry of them all. Yet somehow, he always managed to fall between two stools in getting his records accepted; he was never (whilst alive) that great a hit with blues purists, and his blues roots somehow made him miss the boat of the Soul boom, but in my view, he was an indispensable link between what went before and what can afterwards. And his voice... and that mean harmonica... and an earnestness in his delivery that was so real that at times it almost sounded like a threat. When he sang "I'm gonna love you pretty baby", you knew he wasn't kidding! Perhaps his sides were more suited to jiving than twist-influenced body dancing, for, like all dances that follow a set pre-learnt pattern, so his music had a similar, almost formal structure. One of the true greats of Blackamerican music in my view, and one who will in time, be re-recognised as such. 

MAURICE & MAC "YOU LEFT THE WATER RUNNING" (Written by Rick Hall, Dan Penn & Oscar Franks) CHECKER 1197 available on CHARLY CD "20 R&B DANCE FLOOR FILLERS" CDRB 23

I first encountered this song via Barbara Lynn's superb reading of it for TRIBE in 1966, and, since this Maurice & Mac version was issued in 1968, I assume that her's was the original, but, both are superb renditions of a great song, and certainly Maurice & Mac maintain that great tradition (so close to my own peculiar heart!) of male-duo harmony singing. 


The late Z.Z.Hill has a well deserved reputation in Soul circles, but this track is as good as anything he ever did. From a cleverly (and accurately) titled CD compiled with obvious taste, skill and sound Soul judgement by Adrian Coasdell, this Sam Cooke composition is "classic" Deep Soul; simple to the point of starkness, and yet with an underlying conviction that Hill conveys with some quite superlative vocal gymnastics. The "performance" (and in that I cover not just the singing, but also the "acting" ability; a so-essential ingredient in Deep Soul that is so often overlooked as a factor), is one that ebbs and flows; one moment he is cool(ish), and then, as he takes stock, he surges into a passionate declamatory delivery, which, when backed as it is here by simple rhythm section, guitar, piano and organ, is a formula that, for Deep Soul fans, is sanctifying and an essential side because yes, we do "know what he's talking about"! 

Well, that about all I have space for this time, but in the next edition, I'll continue digging through the "essentials" and trying to sort them from the "semi-essentials"! 

Keep the faith. Right on now !